How Do You Reconcile Crypto Tax Software Totals with Exchange 1099 Forms?
When your crypto tax software reports different totals than the 1099 forms your exchange issued, the exchange forms are often incomplete. You reconcile by identifying which transactions the exchange reported, which it missed, and ensuring your software captures everything you actually did.
Why the numbers don't match
Exchanges issue Form 1099-B or a similar consolidated report only for activity that happened on that specific platform. The form will not include:
- Transfers to or from external wallets
- Trades executed on decentralized exchanges (DEXs)
- On-chain activity such as staking, airdrops, or NFT purchases
- Transactions on other exchanges you used
- Cost basis from coins you moved in from outside the exchange
Your tax software, by contrast, is designed to pull in data from multiple sources - exchange APIs, wallet addresses, CSV uploads - and calculate totals for your entire crypto activity. A mismatch is normal and expected.
Step 1: compare gross proceeds
Start with the simplest number: total proceeds from sales and disposals.
- Find the total proceeds reported on your exchange 1099. This is usually in Box 1d (Proceeds) on Form 1099-B.
- Find the same figure in your tax software. Most software has a summary report that shows total proceeds from all sources.
- If the software total is higher, that is common. The software likely includes proceeds from transactions the exchange never saw - DEX trades, transfers out, or activity on other platforms.
- If the software total is lower, you may have missing data. Check whether the exchange's API import failed for some transactions, or whether you accidentally excluded a wallet.
Step 2: Identify Transactions the Exchange Reported
Most tax software lets you view a list of all transactions and mark which ones came from a specific exchange. Use this feature to isolate only the transactions that match the exchange's 1099.
- Filter your software to show only transactions from that exchange.
- Compare the list against the exchange's downloadable transaction history, not just the 1099 summary. The 1099 may aggregate trades into fewer lines than your software shows.
- Look for trades that appear in the exchange history but are missing from your software. Re-import or manually add those.
Step 3: handle cost basis discrepancies
Even if proceeds match, cost basis often differs. Common reasons:
- The exchange uses a different cost basis method than you selected in your tax software. Exchanges often default to FIFO. If your software uses HIFO or Specific ID, the reported gain or loss per trade will differ.
- The exchange does not know your cost basis for transferred-in coins. If you moved Bitcoin into the exchange from a wallet, the exchange has no record of what you paid for it. It may report the cost basis as zero or leave it blank. Your software should have the correct cost basis from the original purchase.
- The exchange may not apply wash sale adjustments. Even though crypto wash sale rules do not currently apply (as of 2025), the exchange's system may still be set up for securities and incorrectly disallow losses.
To reconcile, compare the software's calculation for each trade against the exchange's number. If they differ, the software's number is likely correct provided your cost basis records are accurate.
Step 4: add missing income items
Exchange 1099 forms generally do not report:
- Staking rewards
- Airdrops
- Mining income
- Interest from lending or DeFi protocols
These are taxable as income in the year received, at fair market value. Your tax software should have separate income reports for these. If the exchange gave you any of these, you need to report them even if they do not appear on the 1099.
Step 5: Report the Correct Totals on Your Tax Return
You do not need to make the software totals match the 1099 exactly. What matters is that the total you report on Form 8949 and Schedule D is accurate for all your activity.
- Attach a statement explaining that the 1099-B totals differ because they cover only on-exchange activity, while your return includes all transactions.
- If the exchange reported incorrect cost basis (e.g., zero for transferred-in coins), you can override the basis on Form 8949 using your own records. Check the "B" box for "basis not reported to IRS" where applicable.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Assuming the 1099 is complete. It almost never is for anyone who uses multiple exchanges, wallets, or DeFi.
- Manually adjusting software totals to match the 1099. This underreports your activity and creates a mismatch with your own records.
- Ignoring small discrepancies. If the difference is a few dollars, the IRS is unlikely to flag it. But if you consistently have large unreported gains, the mismatch becomes noticeable.
- Forgetting to include income items. Staking rewards and airdrops are income, not capital gains. They belong on the income section of your return, not on Form 8949.
When to Use the Exchange's Numbers
The exchange's 1099 is authoritative for one thing: the IRS received a copy. If you report a different total for proceeds on that exchange, and the IRS matches the 1099 against your return, you may get a notice. To avoid that, report the correct total and attach a reconciliation statement. The IRS will ask questions if numbers do not match, but a clear explanation resolves most inquiries.
If you are unsure about any specific transaction, keep the exchange confirmation and your software's audit trail. Both are evidence if you are audited.
Not financial advice. babybuilder.xyz publishes market data and general information about digital assets. Crypto assets are volatile and you can lose everything you put in. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell or hold, and we make no price predictions.
Prices are sourced from third parties and may be delayed or wrong. Verify anything you intend to act on against a primary source.